Showing posts with label how-to. Show all posts
Showing posts with label how-to. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 12, 2014

Proof Argument


Proof Arguments


12 August 2014
Proof is not a document. It’s a body of evidence. As biographers or historians of whatever ilk, we do not ‘prove’ a point by discovering a record that asserts something. That assertion could be wrong. If so, any further work we do on the basis of that misinformation will likely be wrong or irrelevant.
Not even a stack of documents or a list of sources can constitute proof, unless we explain their significance individually and collectively. The piece of writing in which we do this is called a proof argument.
A convincing proof argument will present the evidence from each document. It will frankly discuss the strengths and the weaknesses of each source and the information it provides. It will discuss the contradictions we found and how we resolved them. It will explain how and why, for the issue we are trying to prove, the whole body of evidence points to only one reasonable conclusion.
Achieving proof is a process in which we assemble evidence, test it, refine it, and reinforce it until that body of evidence is solid enough to withstand contradictions and counterclaims. As with any construction project, results are only as good as the materials and the labor we invest.
Need a model to see just how this works? EE's QuickLessons, accessible under the "Home" tab or in the "QuickLesson Archive," provide several of them using a variety of thorny problems


Photo credit: "Two Men Accused Against Himself," CanStockPhoto (http://www.canstockphoto.com/images-photos/argument.html#file_view.php?id=14925683 : downloaded 4 August 2014), used under license.

Thursday, May 08, 2014

Rufnamen

For a period of time Germans often gave their children the same first names as it was thought that the devil could only harm them if their names were known; thus the middle name was the one that was most often used for identification. For example, Jacob Pieter would be Pieter... [I've lost the reference.]
------------------

German Names - Vornamen

German Names
About German names - find here the unique and original description of German names - Vornamen, their origin and history. List of the most fashionable modern German names...

The German word Vorname can be literally translated into English as pre-name. This is a name that German parents give to a newborn child. Among Catholics it often happens that a child has more than one Vorname. However, in informal daily communication people usually call a person by just one name, and this is a Rufname. This is a person's main name, but it often takes the 2d or the 3d place in official papers, as middle names are considered to be more important. 

The name choice may be determined by various reasons. Parents choose the Rufname simply because they like it. Some people have the names of saints as their additional names. There is a popular belief that naming children after saints is a way to secure their patronage. Thus, this practice is not uncommon in religious Catholic families. Some not so religious parents name their children after the prosperous relatives in order to win their favor, often hoping that they might offer some financial aid to the child in the future. However some parents are very liberal, they let the child choose Rufname from several given names.

There are several ways of writing German names. One can specify only the Rufname and the Nachname. The second name may be written in full form or, in American fashion, as a middle initial. A few combinations of male first and second names are traditionally written with a hyphen, e.g. Hans-Joseph.

At least one of these has to be gender specific, while others may be neutral. But in Germany androgynous names are rare.
The fundamental rule is that male names cannot be used for females and otherwise. The only exception to this rule is "Maria". It can be used as a male second name, e.g. Erich Maria Remark.

Abbreviated names are not used officially. So even if Frederick is known among friends as Fred, he will still sign official documents with his full name Frederick.

There are certain restrictive naming regulations in Germany. First of all, a name must be known as a human name. It means that pet names, common nouns, place-names and newly invented names are not allowed. Secondly, it must not be offensive and humiliating so that it does not inflict problems on the bearer in the future. In some cases an unusual name may be allowed provided that the Rufname is a common name.

The Standesbeamter (this is the German word for registrar) has the right to review name choices. A Standesbeamter can bar parents from giving a name if he feels it is unacceptable. For unusual names he might ask for precedent cases. Foreign embassies often have to confirm that this or that name is acceptable. They do that at the instance of immigrants coming from the countries those embassies represent. Parents can appeal the Standesbeamter's decision in court. Such lawsuits, as well as funny names that parents sometimes bestow on their children, are often ridiculed by journalists in the newspapers.
Here are some examples of first names that have been rejected: Christus, Jesus (has been allowed with Spanish surnames), Princess, Prince, Lord, Huckleberry, Cheyenne, Berlin, Stone, Möwe (seagull), Tiger, Moon Unit, AJ, Amsterdam, B'Elanna, Filou, Gift (poison), Frühling (spring - the season), Baby, Golddust, Nightingale, Shiatsu, Tsunami, Villa, Cézanne, Hoffmann, McCoy, Nilsson, Nilson, O'Neill, Picasso, Svensson, Trenk, Wiesengrund. The maximum number of first names is five. Two of them can be hyphenated, however the parts of such names cannot be used separately.
-----------------------

Forenames[edit]

The Vorname (in English forename) is usually given to a child by the parents shortly after birth. It is common to give a child several Vornamen (forenames), one of them intended for everyday use and known as the Rufname ("appellation name"). This Rufname is often underlined on official documents, as it is sometimes the second or third name in the sequence of given names on official record, even though it is the given name in daily use from childhood.[1] For example, in the resume submitted by mathematician Emmy Noether to Erlangen University in 1907,[2]
Ich, Amalie Emmy Noether, bayerischer Staatsangehörigkeit und israelitischer Konfession, bin geboren zu Erlangen am 23. März 1882 ...
"I, Amalie Emmy Noether, of Bavarian nationality and of Israelite confession, born in Erlangen on 23 March 1882 ..."
the underlining of Emmy communicates that this is the Rufname, even though it is the second of two official given names.
In Germany, the chosen name must be approved by the local Standesamt (civil registry office). The name must indicate the gender of the child and not negatively affect the well being of the child. Last names or the names of objects and products are not acceptable. For example, "Matti" was rejected for a boy's name because it did not indicate gender (however, these types of names are permissible if combined with a second name which clarifies the gender, for example: "Matti Oliver" or "Matti Julia").[3][4]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_name
------------
[Perhaps I should order this]:

GGD Newsletter #9 January 1997
Rufnamen - Or a Rose by any other Name" by Elaine D. Schwar by permission of The Journal of the Berks County (PA) Genealogical Society


Tuesday, October 29, 2013

Five Things You Should Do With Every Record

Advanced Research Tip: Five Things You Should Do With Every Record

Posted by Ancestry Anne on October 29, 2013 in Ancestry.com SiteFamily History Month
So you find a record.  It could be through a hint or a search or something is sent to you in the mail.  You attach it to your tree.  Are you done?  No, of course not!  (This would be a very short post if you were done.)
So what do you do before you move onto the next record?
  1. Source the record.  As I mentioned in my article on sourcing, you need to know where the record comes from and who supplied the information.  How can you evaluate the validity of the evidence if you don’t know where the information and who supplied it?  If the info comes from your crazy great aunt it may not be valid.  Or it may be.  But you have an idea of whether you should trust it or not.
  2. Examine the image, not just the index. Never, ever, ever attach a record without looking at the image if the image is available. Not everything on the image is included in the search index. (The search index is there to help you find the image.)  You might miss something.  Just the other day I was looking at my great uncle’s 1940 census record and noticed he had a supplemental line at the bottom.  Low and below it told me that my great uncles father (my great grandfather) served in the Spanish American War and World War I.  If I had just attached the record without thoroughly examining the image, I might have missed an important clue.image18
  3. List all points of genealogical importance. It is amazing how writing something down helps you understand it.  It is too easy to glance at something and not really grasp it.  But if you write every little bit of genealogical data in a record, you might find something you missed.  When was the record recorded? Name each person listed on the record no matter how significant.  Every date, location and relationship you find.  Any assumptions you might have. (Oh, and write down that something is assumption.)  If everything is written down, it is easy to review later.
  4. What questions do you have?   OK, now that you’ve look at the image and gathered everything you can find, what new questions do you have? Do you know who all the people are on the document?  Do you know why that document was created?  Then you can create a plan on how to answer them.
  5. image19File it so you can find it again later.  Raise your hand if you can’t find something in your genealogy files that you know you have.  If your hand is up, you aren’t alone.  Put the information you wrote down somewhere you could find it.  You can put it in a Word file, or a Story on Ancestry online trees.  And if you have Family Tree Maker, then you can put it in the notes files.  And there it is whenever you need it.
Try this on your latest brick wall.  Gather all the records you have for a person and go through them and do all five steps for each record.  You may have the answer right in front of you.  Or you may have asked the right question that will lead you to the answer.
Happy Searching!
    




About Ancestry Anne
Anne Gillespie Mitchell is a Senior Product Manager at Ancestry.com. She is an active blogger on Ancestry.com and writes the Ancestry Anne column and also writes for Ancestry Reference Desk She has been chasing her ancestors through Virginia, North Carolina and South Carolina for many years, and is pursuing her CG certification.
- See more at: http://blogs.ancestry.com/ancestry/2013/10/29/advanced-research-tip-five-things-you-should-do-with-every-record/?hootPostID=b4c6b2009289e64d970839aceb6c7102&o_xid=57458&o_lid=57458&o_sch=Social#sthash.FdN1rK6e.dpuf